FundMiner Blog

The Money That Doesn't Move: The Next Evolution of Fund Management

Written by Joshua Cohen | Nov 16, 2026, 12:52:40 PM

In the 1980s, a donor establishes an endowed scholarship to support students studying Religious Studies. At the time, many institutions had not yet standardized gift agreements. The agreement is brief, the intent is clear, and everyone involved understands exactly how the scholarship should work.

For years, it does.

Students receive awards. The donor receives updates. The department knows the scholarship exists and takes pride in awarding it each year. The system works because the people who created it are still there.

Fast forward forty years.

The donor has passed away. The family still cares deeply about the scholarship and occasionally asks how it is doing. The endowment has continued to grow. The gift agreement still exists.

The institution, however, has changed.

The department merged with another academic unit years ago. Several department chairs have come and gone. The faculty member who championed the scholarship retired. Administrative responsibilities shifted between offices over time. The scholarship committee no longer exists in the form it once did.

Eventually, the scholarship stops being awarded.

Nothing happened to the money.

Nothing happened to the donor's intent.

The institution simply lost the institutional knowledge needed to connect the two.

I suspect that story, or one very much like it, exists at almost every college and university.

Fortunately, higher education has begun paying much more attention to these situations. Organizations like FundMiner and institutions across the country have demonstrated that significant philanthropic resources often remain available long after they could have begun creating impact. As financial pressures continue across higher education, identifying and activating underspent funds has become an increasingly important institutional priority.

That work is incredibly valuable.

It is also only the beginning.

Finding dormant funds should not be the destination. It should be the foundation upon which the next generation of fund management is built.

The problem is rarely the money

When people first hear about underspent funds, the natural assumption is that something has gone wrong financially.

In my experience, that is rarely the case.

The donor gave the gift. The institution accepted it. The endowment continues generating distributions. The money is still available to create impact.

What is usually missing is information.

Sometimes the institution has evolved beyond the original purpose of a fund. Academic programs change, research priorities shift, departments merge, and leadership turns over. In other cases, the challenge is administrative. A new budget manager is unaware the fund exists. A department no longer understands what expenses are permissible. Institutional knowledge gradually disappears through normal turnover.

The specific circumstances differ from institution to institution, and often from fund to fund.

The underlying problem does not.

Underspent funds are fundamentally an information problem.

Once we begin looking at them that way, the future becomes much easier to imagine.

The next evolution of fund management

The current generation of fund management is largely reactive.

A report identifies a fund that has not spent money in several years. Someone investigates. The department is contacted. Questions are answered. A spending plan is developed. Ideally, the fund returns to active use.

That process creates tremendous value.

The question I keep coming back to is what comes next.

Most operational disciplines eventually evolve beyond reporting what already happened. They begin identifying risk before problems occur.

I believe philanthropic fund management is beginning that same transition.

Instead of asking which funds have already become underspent, institutions will begin asking which funds are most likely to become underspent if nothing changes.

That is a fundamentally different question.

It shifts the objective from solving yesterday's problems to protecting tomorrow's opportunities.

Looking twenty years ahead

Now imagine that same scholarship again.

Except this time, it is twenty years from now.

The institution no longer waits until the scholarship has gone three years without an award before noticing something is wrong.

Instead, the scholarship appears on a portfolio health dashboard.

Not because it is underspent.

Because it has become elevated risk.

Over the past several months, a new department chair has been appointed. Similar leadership transitions within that college have historically resulted in temporary lapses in scholarship spending. Administrative ownership has recently changed, and the institution's historical data suggests that funds with this combination of characteristics are more likely to experience interruptions if no action is taken.

Nothing has gone wrong.

The scholarship is still healthy.

The institution simply knows enough to pay attention.

A conversation occurs with the department.

The new chair explains they were unaware the scholarship existed. They receive historical information about how it has traditionally been awarded and discuss whether the original intent still aligns with the department's current structure. The scholarship is awarded the following semester.

No underspent funds report is ever generated.

No years of opportunity are lost.

The intervention happened before the problem existed.

To me, that represents the future state of this profession.

From fund management to portfolio health

The technology behind that future is exciting, but it is not the point.

Whether institutions ultimately use fund health scores, predictive models, risk categories, or some entirely different framework is almost secondary.

The larger shift is moving from managing individual funds after problems occur to continuously understanding the health of the philanthropic portfolio as a whole.

Every institution will define portfolio health differently, and they should. Public institutions differ from private institutions. Foundations operate differently. Spending philosophies differ. Institutional priorities differ.

There should never be one universal definition.

Instead, each institution should define what a healthy portfolio means within its own environment.

To me, a healthy portfolio is one where every fund has an understood status. A fund is actively creating impact, intentionally accumulating resources for a future initiative, or has a documented reason why it is temporarily inactive.

Dormancy itself is not the problem.

Dormancy without intention is.

That distinction changes the conversation from "How many dormant funds do we have?" to "How healthy is our philanthropic portfolio?"

Where data science fits

This is where predictive analytics, fund health scoring, and machine learning become particularly exciting.

Not because they replace professional judgment.

Because they help institutions preserve institutional knowledge and direct human attention where it is most likely to matter.

Every institution possesses decades of historical information describing how its funds behave. Administrative turnover. Spending history. Fund purpose. Distribution utilization. Organizational changes. Hundreds of other variables that, taken together, describe how philanthropy functions within that institution.

Modern data science gives us the opportunity to learn from those patterns.

Rather than relying exclusively on reports that describe the past, institutions can begin identifying combinations of characteristics that have historically preceded underspending within their own environment. Those patterns are unlikely to be the same everywhere, which is exactly why institution-specific models become so valuable.

This is not fundamentally an artificial intelligence problem.

It is an information management problem that modern data science is finally mature enough to help address.

The prediction itself is not the decision.

It is the beginning of a better conversation.

Looking ahead

Higher education has always evolved.

Forty years ago, the profession focused primarily on fundraising.

Twenty years ago, stewardship became a discipline in its own right, giving donors a clearer understanding of the impact of their generosity.

Today, institutions are rightly focused on activating philanthropic resources that have quietly sat unused.

Over the next one to two decades, I expect the institutions leading this space to take the next step.

They will not simply identify dormant funds more efficiently.

They will continuously monitor portfolio health, identify emerging risks, and intervene before preventable barriers keep donor dollars from creating impact.

At many institutions, a donor can establish a permanent legacy with an endowed gift of approximately $100,000. In return, the institution accepts the responsibility of honoring that donor's intent not for years, but indefinitely.

Meeting that responsibility will require more than fundraising and more than stewardship.

It will require institutions to preserve institutional knowledge, understand the health of every philanthropic resource entrusted to them, and recognize tomorrow's challenges before they become tomorrow's problems.

To me, that is the next evolution of fund management.

The money that doesn't move will always exist.

Our responsibility is to ensure it rarely stays that way.

Learn how you can spend funds, deliver impact, and send reports, all inside FundMiner.